November 12, 2026
Florida voters approved Amendment 3, and Sarasota County passed it with 62.6% of the vote. On Longboat Key, the town and both counties face lost revenue, and local projects could be affected.
Statewide coverage of the amendment has mostly been about the homestead number. Longboat Key's owners are a different mix. In its October 29 look at what the vote meant for the island, the Observer described Longboat as "a coastal community mostly consisting of seasonal residents with properties assessed at seven digits and above."
For a homesteaded Longboat owner, the paper estimated annual property tax bills would drop by about $1,400 on the Sarasota County side and about $1,710 on the Manatee County side by fiscal year 2029. That's real money. Against a seven-figure assessment, though, it's a modest share of the bill, because the exemption is a flat dollar amount. School taxes are usually the largest part of a property tax bill, and the expanded exemption doesn't reduce them. Neither does it reduce assessments for services such as solid waste or stormwater, according to Sarasota County's Amendment 3 page.
Starting January 1, 2027, the non-school assessed value of qualifying non-homestead residential property can rise no more than 5% a year, down from 10%. The cap limits how fast the taxable assessment grows. It doesn't set tax rates, and it doesn't apply to school levies.
The same arithmetic that lowers some bills reduces what the town and both counties collect. Property taxes make up 75% of Longboat Key's general fund, and the town expects to lose about $1.4 million in fiscal year 2029, the Observer reported. Before the vote, Town Commissioner BJ Bishop asked in that article, "Will we have to raise fees at the tennis center?" Town Manager George Landry listed landscaping, road repaving, rainy-day funds and beach renourishment as areas that could be affected. Landry also said that if revenue dropped, raising the millage to replace it was the last thing he would propose.
The most visible project at stake is at Town Center Green. On the Monday before the election, the Town Commission unanimously gave final approval to Sarasota County's plan for a library branch on the town-owned park. The park sits among Publix, the tennis center, Town Hall and the Longboat Key Club. The design added expanded meeting space and an outdoor terrace facing the Karon Family Pavilion bandshell. A private fundraising campaign led by the town and the Longboat Key Foundation paid for those additions. It raised $4 million, including a $1 million pledge from U.S. Rep. Vern Buchanan, and the library was to carry his name.
The Observer's November 3 report noted that Sarasota County leaders had said the library would be scrapped before ground was broken if the amendment passed. After the vote, the paper's November 5 coverage said county leaders had named the joint project a potential first cut. The county had budgeted $11 million for it. If it's cut, the town could be left holding money for meeting space and a terrace with no library to attach them to.
The north end has its own stake. Manatee County had explored Longboat Island Chapel as a north-end community center in a collaboration among the county, the church and Paradise Center. Before the vote, Manatee County Commission Chair Tal Siddique said the county-funded improvements depended on the amendment failing. He also said, "We're absolutely going to cut (the community center) and a few other things."
The town and both counties lose revenue, and the Town Center Green library and the north-end community center are the first projects named as cuts.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Searching for your dream home in the Sunshine State? Look no further! Jessica Ross is your dedicated Florida real estate expert, ready to guide you on an exciting journey towards finding the perfect property.